Pages

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Dad Shoots Laptop – Is Facebook Humiliation Sensible or Not?


I’m sure by now most people have seen the video of the dad shooting his daughter’s laptop because of a message she posted on Facebook vilifying her parents for assigning too many chores.  It’s went viral online and snippets of it have been covered in local broadcast news. Here’s a link to the video in case you haven’t seen it.



A lot of people have shown support for the Dad while opponents felt he stooped to a child’s level and his rant was excessively violent.  While I can’t really say whether he was right or wrong as I am still parenting toddlers and preschoolers at this point, I do empathize with a parent’s feeling of being at wits' end and willing to try anything discipline wise to get your child’s behavior to change for better.  I am not a fan of brandishing guns, particularly when children are present. However, had one of my daughters posted that venomous message about me and her Dad on Facebook, I am sure I’d be extremely hurt, angry and ready to rip her a new one.  

I think one of my most diplomatic parenting resources, Positive Parenting Solutions, probably offers the sanest opinion on the dad's method of discipline. In many ways, such an extreme response from this father may have irreparably damaged a long-term relationship with his daughter.
 
What do you all think? Do you think the Dad’s actions were justified? Do you agree with how he handled his daughter’s tirade on Facebook? Or, do you think shooting the laptop was too violent? Do you feel Facebook humiliation is an effective way to discipline kids? 

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Dad Shoots Laptop – Is Facebook Humiliation Sensible or Not?


I’m sure by now most people have seen the video of the dad shooting his daughter’s laptop because of a message she posted on Facebook vilifying her parents for assigning too many chores.  It’s went viral online and snippets of it have been covered in local broadcast news. Here’s a link to the video in case you haven’t seen it.



A lot of people have shown support for the Dad while opponents felt he stooped to a child’s level and his rant was excessively violent.  While I can’t really say whether he was right or wrong as I am still parenting toddlers and preschoolers at this point, I do empathize with a parent’s feeling of being at wits' end and willing to try anything discipline wise to get your child’s behavior to change for better.  I am not a fan of brandishing guns, particularly when children are present. However, had one of my daughters posted that venomous message about me and her Dad on Facebook, I am sure I’d be extremely hurt, angry and ready to rip her a new one.  

I think one of my most diplomatic parenting resources, Positive Parenting Solutions, probably offers the sanest opinion on the dad's method of discipline. In many ways, such an extreme response from this father may have irreparably damaged a long-term relationship with his daughter.
 
What do you all think? Do you think the Dad’s actions were justified? Do you agree with how he handled his daughter’s tirade on Facebook? Or, do you think shooting the laptop was too violent? Do you feel Facebook humiliation is an effective way to discipline kids? 

No comments:

Post a Comment